ABC/HR Version 0.9b, 30 August 2002
Testname: 

1R = D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 2] ButterflyLovers.wav
2L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,50] ButterflyLovers.wav
3L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 6,00] ButterflyLovers.wav
4L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,99] ButterflyLovers.wav
5L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 3] ButterflyLovers.wav
6R = D:\Temp\HQ test\[MPC SV7 1.14 -q 5] ButterflyLovers.wav

---------------------------------------
General Comments:

---------------------------------------
1R File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 2] ButterflyLovers.wav
1R Rating: 3.5
1R Comment: violin is slightly aggressive on high-pitched notes (probably something close to ringing)
---------------------------------------
2L File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,50] ButterflyLovers.wav
2L Rating: 2.0
2L Comment: coarseness.
Very strange and agressive phenomenon on orchestra: originally smooth, and here broken, irregular. It also give the feeling of a ping-pong stereo (it's maybe a simple ringing, but I suspect something else). Anyway, it's really bad....
Range: 10.00 - 17.00
---------------------------------------
4L File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,99] ButterflyLovers.wav
4L Rating: 2.0
4L Comment: exactly the same problems than 2L. Maybe slightly worse. I've just noticed a better range for the problem: 16.0 - 18.0. My feeling is more precise now: no more stereo problems, but ringing (serious holes are probably visible through an editor).
---------------------------------------
5L File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 3] ButterflyLovers.wav
5L Rating: 3.0
5L Comment: chewing-gum sound, with remanance.
---------------------------------------
6R File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[MPC SV7 1.14 -q 5] ButterflyLovers.wav
6R Rating: 3.0
6R Comment: This file sounds a bit "fat" (lack of airness?). I'm not sure.
---------------------------------------
ABX Results:
Original vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 2] ButterflyLovers.wav
    9 out of 12, pval = 0.073
Original vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,50] ButterflyLovers.wav
    11 out of 12, pval = 0.003
Original vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 6,00] ButterflyLovers.wav
    2 out of 12, pval = 0.997
Original vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,99] ButterflyLovers.wav
    12 out of 12, pval < 0.001
Original vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 3] ButterflyLovers.wav
    11 out of 12, pval = 0.003
Original vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[MPC SV7 1.14 -q 5] ButterflyLovers.wav
    10 out of 12, pval = 0.019