ABC/HR Version 0.9b, 30 August 2002 Testname: 1L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 6,00] krall#03 (short).wav 2L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[MPC SV7 1.14 -q 5] krall#03 (short).wav 3R = D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,99] krall#03 (short).wav 4L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,50] krall#03 (short).wav 5L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 2] krall#03 (short).wav 6L = D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 3] krall#03 (short).wav --------------------------------------- General Comments: --------------------------------------- 1L File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 6,00] krall#03 (short).wav 1L Rating: 3.2 1L Comment: cymbals are too brilliant, and sounds in consequence distorted. Little annoying --------------------------------------- 2L File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[MPC SV7 1.14 -q 5] krall#03 (short).wav 2L Rating: 3.0 2L Comment: distortions (fluctuant sound). Little annoying --------------------------------------- 3R File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,99] krall#03 (short).wav 3R Rating: 2.0 3R Comment: same comment --------------------------------------- 4L File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,50] krall#03 (short).wav 4L Rating: 2.0 4L Comment: same comment (maybe slightly better than previous file) --------------------------------------- 5L File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 2] krall#03 (short).wav 5L Rating: 2.0 5L Comment: distortions are annoying me. It sounds like 2L and 3R, but with additional smearing problem (not really obvious, but perceptible) --------------------------------------- 6L File: D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 3] krall#03 (short).wav 6L Rating: 1.5 6L Comment: really distorted, with audible lack in sharpness. Voice suffers from distortion too (typical of lame or Nero AAC problem: ATH?) --------------------------------------- ABX Results: Original vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 6,00] krall#03 (short).wav 59 out of 100, pval = 0.044 Original vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[MPC SV7 1.14 -q 5] krall#03 (short).wav 16 out of 20, pval = 0.006 D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 6,00] krall#03 (short).wav vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[MPC SV7 1.14 -q 5] krall#03 (short).wav 19 out of 42, pval = 0.780 D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,99] krall#03 (short).wav vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,50] krall#03 (short).wav 40 out of 70, pval = 0.141 D:\Temp\HQ test\[aoTuV MGX -q 5,50] krall#03 (short).wav vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 2] krall#03 (short).wav 5 out of 14, pval = 0.910 D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 2] krall#03 (short).wav vs D:\Temp\HQ test\[MP3 3.97a3 -V 3] krall#03 (short).wav 25 out of 32, pval = 0.001