ABC/HR for Java, Version 0.5a, 18 août 2005
Testname: 

Tester: guruboolez

1L = E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [AAC faac].wav
2L = E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [AAC Nero Digital].wav
3L = E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [MPC 1.15v].wav
4R = E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [MP3 LAME].wav
5L = E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [vorbis aoTuV].wav

---------------------------------------
General Comments: 
---------------------------------------
1L File: E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [AAC faac].wav
1L Rating: 4.5
1L Comment: Maybe... I guess... I'm not sure... Go to ABX module.
After ABX: the minor "thing" really exists. Strings are a bit different.
---------------------------------------
2L File: E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [AAC Nero Digital].wav
2L Rating: 3.5
2L Comment: Violins are not transparent; there's a form of 'acidity' [I see it like this] on these instruments (I mean orchestra, not solo violin).
---------------------------------------
3L File: E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [MPC 1.15v].wav
3L Rating: 3.5
3L Comment: Orchestra sounds fat. It's clear on 8.0 - 12.0 range. I'd bet it's Vorbis and usual coarseness issue.
---------------------------------------
4R File: E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [MP3 LAME].wav
4R Rating: 4.8
4R Comment: Minor difference I can 'feel' - I need to ABX them.
After ABX: difference was very hard to catch. Really good encoding, though it's not *fully* transparent.
---------------------------------------

ABX Results:
Original vs E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [MP3 LAME].wav
    13 out of 16, pval = 0.01
Original vs E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [AAC faac].wav
    12 out of 12, pval < 0.001
Original vs E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [vorbis aoTuV].wav
    9 out of 16, pval = 0.401


---- Detailed ABX results ----
Original vs E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [MP3 LAME].wav
Playback Range: 09.518 to 16.630
    4:09:27 AM p 1/1 pval = 0.5
    4:09:33 AM p 2/2 pval = 0.25
    4:09:41 AM f 2/3 pval = 0.5
    4:09:46 AM p 3/4 pval = 0.312
    4:09:54 AM f 3/5 pval = 0.5
    4:09:59 AM f 3/6 pval = 0.656
    4:10:05 AM p 4/7 pval = 0.5
    4:10:10 AM p 5/8 pval = 0.363
    4:10:17 AM p 6/9 pval = 0.253
    4:10:20 AM p 7/10 pval = 0.171
    4:10:34 AM p 8/11 pval = 0.113
    4:10:43 AM p 9/12 pval = 0.072
    4:10:56 AM p 10/13 pval = 0.046
    4:11:02 AM p 11/14 pval = 0.028
    4:11:15 AM p 12/15 pval = 0.017
    4:11:21 AM p 13/16 pval = 0.01

Original vs E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [AAC faac].wav
Playback Range: 03.850 to 13.903
    4:06:54 AM p 1/1 pval = 0.5
    4:07:06 AM p 2/2 pval = 0.25
    4:07:16 AM p 3/3 pval = 0.125
    4:07:23 AM p 4/4 pval = 0.062
    4:07:30 AM p 5/5 pval = 0.031
    4:07:37 AM p 6/6 pval = 0.015
    4:07:43 AM p 7/7 pval = 0.0070
    4:07:48 AM p 8/8 pval = 0.0030
    4:08:01 AM p 9/9 pval = 0.0010
Playback Range: 17.592 to 27.699
    4:08:27 AM p 10/10 pval < 0.001
    4:08:35 AM p 11/11 pval < 0.001
    4:08:40 AM p 12/12 pval < 0.001

Original vs E:\SUMMER TESTS 2005\HQ180\18_Butterfly [vorbis aoTuV].wav
Playback Range: 09.518 to 16.630
    4:11:43 AM f 0/1 pval = 1.0
    4:11:49 AM f 0/2 pval = 1.0
    4:11:56 AM f 0/3 pval = 1.0
    4:12:02 AM f 0/4 pval = 1.0
    4:12:08 AM p 1/5 pval = 0.968
    4:12:11 AM p 2/6 pval = 0.89
    4:12:18 AM p 3/7 pval = 0.773
    4:12:22 AM p 4/8 pval = 0.636
    4:12:30 AM f 4/9 pval = 0.746
    4:12:34 AM p 5/10 pval = 0.623
    4:12:44 AM p 6/11 pval = 0.5
    4:12:48 AM p 7/12 pval = 0.387
    4:12:51 AM f 7/13 pval = 0.5
    4:13:00 AM p 8/14 pval = 0.395
    4:13:08 AM f 8/15 pval = 0.5
    4:13:17 AM p 9/16 pval = 0.401

